Going to the Mall for Christmas?

Looks like it's up to 4 million views! Wow, that's rivaling the Macy's Philadelphia one.

This gives me goosebumps every time!  I like to think it's a foretaste of heaven, when the community of Jesus breaks out into song any time anywhere, and Holy to the Lord will be inscribed on the bells of the horses, and every pot will be holy to the Lord, and every mall and food court will be a holy place of singing and fellowship.

Amen

This is going to be a rather "Bah-humbug" comment for something I enjoyed viewing as well. But here's some grist for the discernment mill, from Jamie Smith:

"So what to make of these irruptions of the Messiah in the food court? How should we think about these insertions of the church's music in the mall? Does this represent a little "redemption" of the mall, a reorientation of the mall's liturgies?

I don't think so. For at least a couple of reasons.

First, while we might associate this with "liturgical," high-churchy music, in these flash mob performances it only functions as an event. Liturgies are formative precisely because they are repetitive, shaping us over time within the context of the Christian story as it is "carried" in the practices of worship. Too much of North American evangelicalism already thinks of worship as merely an expressive event, and these flash mob events do nothing to displace that.

Second, these irruptive events do nothing to counter the formative effects and disordered telos of the mall's consumerism. Indeed if anything, they provide comfort to such practices--injecting a little dose of transcendence into the frantic pursuit for stuff, thus leaving the shoppers to happily continue on their way after the event."    (Read the rest here)

So is this being Scrooge or simply being shrewd (ala. Matt. 10:14)?

It's an event, not a liturgy, and therefore not formative.   

It supports the mall's culture instead of reforming it.

With these arguments, Smith dismisses the mall Messiah.   And I called it a foretaste of heaven! 

I wonder if critiquing it in terms of whether it's a liturgy is quite fair.   Granted the concerns Smith raises, yet I think he's a bit too humbuggy.  I want to leave room for the occasional one-time, unique prophetic event.  The symbolic.  The impact of the one burning bush you'll ever see (or recognize).   

Could it be that in spite of its shortfalls, it could work as a sign? Could it still function in some redemptive way?   Bringing genuine beauty into the front lines of the fray?  Bringing a moment of contemplation to the midst of the chaos?    don't sell it short.