Skip to main content

Here is an interesting study: (click on instrumentation for a link) 

In Christ Alone

Keith/Kristyn Getty

Handbells

Organ

Choir  

Praise God From Whom All Blessings Flow/Old Hundredth (originally set with Psalm 134)

A capella (with Psalm 134 its original pairing)

Organ

Ralph Vaughan Williams arr:

Praise Band:

Is one version more "authentic" than another? Certainly

Are the lesser "authentic" versions wrong or simply different?

Certainly not every song can cross over between genres but might there not be more fluidity than we think?  Should we not be grateful that a congregation that uses organ can be blessed by singing "In Christ Alone" and that a praise band can sing the doxology with a tune and words that are so well-known? 

Joyce Borger on March 2, 2010

In reply to by anonymous_stub (not verified)

Many good points have been made here. And let me assure you that many of them have been thought through. As suggested I will start a new thread regarding the new hymnal and pick up on this conversation there.

Joyce Borger on February 22, 2010

In reply to by anonymous_stub (not verified)

We are trying to include contemporary music in "Lift Up Your Hearts" (a new CRC/RCA hymnal set to come out in 2013). Obviously we face the issue of how long it takes to get things in print (i.e. are they still contemporary or have they fallen by the way). But, would you recommend these songs for the hymnal (need to fit on 2-3 pages). [see: http://www.crcna.org/pages/hymnal.cfm ]

There will be an online component through www.hymnary.org which will allow people to download music/lead sheets/text who don't want to buy the hymnal for all their congregants.

-Joyce

We want to hear from you.

Connect to The Network and add your own question, blog, resource, or job.

Add Your Post